on Wednesday we spent the class in the writing center mimicking instructors in search of plagiarism. i think either my group did a pretty good job at concealment or perhaps my first attempt at plagiarism spotting did not go so well. when Scot and the other instructors came in to speak about plagiarism, they made it seem so easy to detect and find the source. i definitely had a hard time and found nothing for about half an hour.
at first i was searching entire sentences with quotations as Scot had suggested. that returned very few results if any at all; in any case none which proved plagiarism. then i figured i'd shorten the sentences to phrases and sometimes even just words. this improved my search results slightly, but now i was getting too much material. my final trick was to keep the longer phrases but take out the quotation marks, and was finally able to find a few sources.
i can now see the ethics behind plagiarism from the grading instructor's point of view. we looked at only a couple papers, whereas a TA porobably looks at 60+ papers. imagine taking my struggles in searching for plagiarism and multiplying that by 60+. i can see now why some instructors get mad at students for plagiarizing, on top of the fact that it is just plain wrong.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
It took me awhile to find sources that were plagiarized, too. It definitely depends on the topic and how many sources you have to look through!
If I were a teacher, I think I would only search for plagiarism if I had a pretty strong feeling that I am right about it. It would just take too long otherwise!
As you said, you looked for a considerable amount of time without any results. While you knew the paper was plagiarized, a teacher has only his or her suspicions. I can't help but wonder how anyone is caught if they do anything but the most blatant of plagiarisms. I don't really see a TA or a Professor spending over half an hour on a suspicion; particularly when considering they probably have dozens more to look at. Of course, I would also postulate that the typical plagiarist is in a panic and doesn't exactly have the time to do any sort of quality work.
Post a Comment